[Laguna Seca Blue]

What precisely would be the basis for suing them? Seems like there was an accident, they fessed up to it without you having to prompt them, and are now fixing it. Judging by the location, you may not have even noticed it until well after picking up the vehicle by which time it would have been to late to pin it in the dealership. I’d say they’ve shown as much integrity as can be reasonably expected. There are plenty of company’s that deserve a good suing. This is not one of them.

The main thing you want to discuss with them is keeping if off the CARFAX or providing with diminished value compensation if it does end up on the CARFAX. If they go through their commercial insurance or the shop’s DMS software reports to CARFAX, it’s inevitable but they should compensate you for that.