I think he got it right. I’d be biased toward the Alfa since it’s the only truly sporty car there, but it’s hard to live with the typical FCA cheap interior and overall lackluster build quality.
The Bimmer is the best all rounder for sure.
My dad is was in the market and couldn’t find a “sport” sedan in this class that was as fun to drive and as luxurious as his E90...so he got a Macan S. It’s got a better combination of driving dynamics and interior/build quality than any of these cars could dream of.
